I'll presume you're a feudal lord, and that it's a city or a temple. Jun 9, 2019. Churches require theocracy (you just give this away). How do i change these into tribes? (since i assume thats what they. Source. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. I fabricated a claim and captured the county, usurping the prince-bishop. Or in your realm if you invite them to your court first. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. At the moment, my count appears as ruler of the county, but I'm barely collecting any tax - as apparently it's the wrong type of. Questions on Ck2: How to fix "holder is of the wrong holding type" and how do I know who I am at war with? I'm Norway - so I am tribal and then I build a temple. The. But I can't give it away. Is it possible to change this city into a castle. So I was playing the demo earlier and an 'alert button' popped up saying that a few of my provinces were the wrong type of holding in my demesne. I conquered Rome but had wrong hold type since the capital of the county was a temple. Barons have baronies, mayors have cities, and bishops have bishoprics. Dec 30, 2013 @ 7:55pm wrong type of holding im playing a game, i beat a muslim place on a holy war and take it over, i now have a wrong type of holding warning. . I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. Wrong holding just eat money but characters will actually accumulate wealth and build stuff here, btw keeping taxes low you speed up development. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. ago • Edited 8 yr. maybe like 75% of the income and 60% of the levy would be realistic. Currently, the game doesnt really care that you are tribal when you conquer normal lands and simply gives you a standard "wrong holding" penalty or a "wrong government type. - When the mod is enabled, you (as well as the AI) can build unique castle upgrades in your capital holding. Tribalism is an early form of government, and one of three playable non-feudal government types in CK2 (the other two being merchant republics and. Hi My question is, what are the consequences (cons and maybe there are some pros) of having a a wrong holding type or a big demense? From what I know: Cons of having a big demense: - Problems with taxes? Cons of having a wrong holding type: -. Even i give to a vassal, that time the opinion of me -30 for wrong type of holding government. Then you can hand out the city to someone else, (preferably a mayor) and you'd have a de jure claim on the former Duke of Munster's territory or go after the Duke first and let him worry about the "wrong holding type" in Ormond. Unless it's out of date. So it’s only fair to give ck3 years to catch up on features. Wrong settlement type [edit | edit source] Characters get a 75% penalty to income and levies in demesne settlements that do not match their government type. But I can't give it away. Ck2 Holder Is Of Wrong Holding Type Mod Thé Game. Okay, so I was playing as the Most Serene Doge of Genoa. Building holdings, especially cities pays off after a few centuries, so if you are in for the long haul it's a sensible decision, cities in particular are good for the long term as they make so much money they build all improvements on their own (even universities). I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. Anyway, got a new problem that I can't seem to work out, hope you guys can help. But I can't give it away. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. Dear CK2 players, Somehow one of my county capitals is a city. Each of these three types have an associated. . Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without. The second is to get a big fat capital, like 6 or 7 slots, and just build castles and hold them all yourself. 8-bit Sep 1, 2018 @ 12:13am. By Arqam 2023-05-14 2023-05-14 ShareYes, you should in theory be able to convert a Metropolis holding to whatever other holding type you want. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Exothermically Eclectic Dec 30, 2013 @ 8:07pm. . This includes Cities of Wonders 2, which we've previously featured and introduces a fourth type of holding – the metropolis. It gives you a warning but it doesn't explain what are the problems with it, just to change it. . Either to an unlanded courtier, previously landed vassal or a newly created one through the given holding's menu. They pay lower taxes than cities and temples, but provide better levies, both in quality and quantity. I hold Leicester as Earl. If you don't use Ironman for your current game, you can open the console by typing any of the following: On German/Nordic keyboards, this is ⇧Shift + 3 This may also be the combo of left shift and the §| key to the left of the number 1 on the number row. Noob player, I had the following scenario in my game: Started as a Count controlling a single county. . . However, my problem is that apparently every holding in England is of the wrong type. There are five types of settlements, each with a different set of buildings. Holding multiple castles in a single county is better than only holding one castle in a single county, but worse than holding a single castle in multiple counties. It dictates the available succession laws and holdings of a character, and some government types have unique mechanics. You can either left click on the province, right click on the icon in the province menu that pops up of the holding you want to give away, then hit the little crown icon to generate a new vassal holding that title, or you can find. Am I supposed to spend a bunch of money to upgrade the tribe into a castle? I think that "wrong holding type" actually means "wrong government" You would get a Malus to income and levies from that holding, 75% Malus to both i think. - Added Casus Belli type flags 'apply_short_occ_mod' and 'apply_short_occ_mod'. For that to happen, he has to own both the capital and a holding of his preferred type. It advises assigning vassals to manage them properly. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Why is it bad to govern cities directly? I am guessing it is bad since I got the message warning me. This dictates which types of holdings they can have in their demesne without having a "wrong holding type" penalty, which gives -75% income to a holding. was finally able to revoke a few of his titles for heresy, but the new (previously unlanded) owner immediatley took a "wrong holding type" penalty. Each form of government has preferred and allowed settlements, and will get "Wrong government type" (-75% levies and income) penalty while holding other types of settlements directly. I now get the warning/message "Wrong type of holding in Demesne"; what does that do? It doesn't say what penalties there are. What is…Think about all the types of characters we could play using character interaction and (hopefully expanded) Way of Life-type mechanics. Holdings produce all levies and taxes, and are thus important, yet easily ignored. I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. Bedford has a castle and I'm still tribal. They also can't get 100% out of castles they hold. However, my problem is that apparently every holding in England is of the wrong type. anyway. Business, Economics, and Finance. May 6, 2013 @ 2:55pm. 'Wrong Type of Holding' = SO CONFUSED. Got in and discovered what's happened. I have managed to give it away, thanks for the tip. Engage in. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Once he/she is a feudal vassal, give him/her the rest of the tribal holdings for much faster conversion to feudal. To start with, the basics are fairly simple. But I can't give it away. These holdings provide both income and taxes, and every holding is held by a character. Most characters cannot hold a city within their direct demesne without suffering. Just now, I finished constructing a new city in the county where my ruler resides. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. as you cannot build multiple tribal holdings in one county and get crippling penalties for wrong holding type. It gives you a warning but it doesn't explain what are the problems with it, just to change it. Or you can select the city and click on the button to have the game choose a mayor for you. . What exactly does this mean?The change log for 1. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. what do I do if I want to retain control of it and get rid of that warning!So, I'm the king of England. Wrong type of holding in demesne. More info available in _governments. 2 mrt 2013 om 20:20 Can someone please explain "Wrong Type of Holding in Demesne" to me :(. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. Also you cannot hold a holding that does not correspond to your type of government without penalty. >). I'm playing the Amalfi merchant republic and have expanded to hold the republic of Sicily, there are a few of my vassals that have the wrong government type modifier which is a bit of a downer so I'm wondering, how do I fix this?Destroying holdings won't overpass the balance issue of having at least 1 of each type of holding in every province: it will only free a holding slot. txt file. Great Holy war/Jihad - usurp entire kingdom. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. Yes it is a differnt (therefore wrong) type of holding. There are a few holdings here and there that imo are the wrong type for whatever reason. This mod brings the benefits of a family palace to feudal rulers, and also adds flavor random events and decisions. Sounds like I need to usurp the claim on the county. I got this message when I revoked the title of major of Sigtuna (a city) from an underling. how do I change it so the county is controlled by the castle? (i know how to change the owners of the wrong demense type, but in current format I can only gove the. Edit: I found that I could just 'give landed title' away the Fylkja title and that 'fixed' it, but still. Not sure of exact percentages but you get a lot less levy and gold from them. Young knights. My personal opinion: The rule for building new holdings is that the county needs to have 1 of each holding before you can build a second holding of the same type. Sep 9, 2020. anyway. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Wrong type of holding? But they told me to build a church! I got a quest from my Monastic Order to build a new church. Holding type. . Step3: Give away the. A different Baron, which is my vassal, holds this title. By wrong type of holding I mean being a duke and holding a territory whose ruler should be a bishop. You lose 75% of the. Is there any was to change the county capital to a barony? Does it hurt me to hold a county that is the wrong type of holding?So im still not understanding this right. ago. i'm now getting a. Holy stays at just 25. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Is it impossible to change Holding Type?This is the second part of a four-part (I, IIa, IIb, III, IV) series examining the historical assumptions of the popular historical grand strategy game Crusader Kings III, by Paradox Interactive. It has a city, barony and bishopry. Crusade does not - theres a special effect that auto creates new vassals for city and temple holdings. Support me on patreon : me a tad of your time and support the channel for free on TAD : Can't construct new holding. the only way to really avoid the penalty is to build a tribal holding in one of the empty slots if it is available. ago No. New player here; my son and I just bought CK2 a few days ago. I have conquered a neighbouring county but it's capital has a stone castle - for this I am now getting a wrong. Are there any prerequisites I need to meet?Crusader Kings 2 is almost 5 years old, but the developers at Paradox are still producing new content for it in the form of patches and DLC. If these two aren't enough for you,. Each of these three types have an associated character type; baronies are typically owned by nobles, cities by. Wrong Government Type The wrong government type opinion modifier is applied whenever a Count-level or higher character has a liege who is of a different character type. So im still not understanding this right. This works well, especially in coastal duchies (extra buildings for cities basically double their tax income). Im confused what the message "Wrong type of holding in demense" means. Note that this means the type of one or more of your provinces could change when you become a republic. Castles are the county seat for most counties; as such, their higher fort level as compared to temples and cities helps the county to better withstand sieges and raids. im playing a game, i beat a muslim place on a holy war and take it over, i now have a wrong type of holding warning. Because whenever I assign a landed title I see the levy is. Horse Lords and Conclave, the two masterpieces of DLCs combined and produced an even greater masterpiece - the never ending, unkillable, half-ethereal, half-reinforcing hosts: 1. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. To create the new vassal either nightclick a character and grant them the title, or click the Wrong Type of Holding Pop-Up and rightclick the Holding on the bottom left and press on Create New Vassal. But I can't give it away. ahahah_effeffeffe_2 • 16 days ago. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. The Crusader Kings III Convert Holdings mod – which you can grab from the Steam Workshop – is compatible with "pretty much all mods", according to creator kurthakon. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. So im still not understanding this right. Is there any way or maybe a mod out there that reduces the penalty for holding a wrong type of holding. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. It is possible for you to build a castle in this county and then you will be able to designate the castle as the county's new capital barony. Horse Lords and Conclave, the two masterpieces of DLCs combined and produced an even greater masterpiece - the never ending, unkillable, half-ethereal, half-reinforcing hosts: 1. They pay the most taxes, and once upgraded give numerous levies, but have a lower fort level than castles and their levies consist more of the lighter soldier types than both castles and temples. The penalty you get is less taxes and troops from the "wrong type" holding. 1. Great Holy war/Jihad - usurp entire kingdom. Dear CK2 players, Somehow one of my county capitals is a city. Anyone has any ideas?For the counties I usually go to the intrigue tab to recruit a noble/soldier/holy men. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god. Langkard Aug 31, 2018 @ 6:31pm. I have a warning message that the city and. Also, if you are not at your demesne limit you can hold onto wrong holdings. . They pay the most taxes, and once upgraded give numerous levies, but have a lower fort level than castles and their levies consist more of the lighter soldier types than both castles and temples. CryptoSo, I'm the king of England. How do i change these into tribes? (since i assume thats what they. I beat it, get 3 prestige and 0. Money in CK2 has a lot of uses. You can only do this to your holdings which are feudal. top of page. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. Anyone has any ideas?Select the barony. I'm Norway - so I am tribal and then I build a temple. Now, im not a CK2 novice, I know im not allowed cities or bishoprics but these are castles. Instead, Khagans will be increasingly pressured to give out excess nomadic counties (defined as counties with 0 or 1 settlement) to vassal clans (or to start a new clan), as excess counties lower clan sentiment, which lowers vassal khans' opinion towards the Khagan. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. Making the castle your capital would be a major mistake. My government type was landless for a bit there . So im still not understanding this right. What you need to do is build a tribal holding in one of the subslots and turn that into the county capital and then give the castle away preferably to a random dude. Don't get me wrong, I feel your frustration, but when you consider how many variables are being checked at any given time in-game, it's not all that surprising how. How do i change these into tribes? (since i assume thats what they. Unless you're playing as a Merchant Republic, you are a feudal character. In a separate issue, I have towns/castles that I can't upgrade because it says I don't have Keeps II which I do have. . Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne Ck2. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. Holdings can be Castles, Cities, or Temples. Say for example, somehow a character who ONLY holds a city or church. #5. . Wrong Type Of Holding In Demesne Ck2 Mac Linux Developed. Each city you give is +20 relation. How do i change these into tribes? (since i assume thats what they. There are three types of holdings: Baronies: Focus on troops. PK SPACE JAM. Is it possible to change this city into a castle so the wrong holding type penalty will disappear?Crusader Kings 2 is almost 5 years old, but the developers at Paradox are still producing new content for it in the form of patches and DLC. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. Xihu. All the empty baronies are useless to tribal rulers. Sounds like you're tribal and the holding is feudal. Oh, yes - you also get money from them. Special decisions allow tribes and nomads to. anyway. So I reformed the Germanic religion, then the head dies and I am now the head of the religion setting my government type to ~LANDLESS~ and now Ive got a problem because literally every holding is of the wrong type now for me. You can see it has a city as county capital but it's held by a duke (noble) so it's the wrong type of holding. There are 6 different character/government types a character ingame can has, from which 3 are available to players. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. Tribal rulers can only hold tribes without. . anyway. Edit: I found that I could just 'give landed title' away the Fylkja title and that 'fixed' it, but still. It isn't listed as one of my demesnes that I can assign to someone else. *Yes of course you can hold as many duchies holding as you want, and ignore the liege holds de jure duchy stuff if you want and have other bonuses to relations or a lot of dread. It doesn't get met any money or levies, yet I can't grant it to a mayor as I would usually do, only to vassal wich makes me lose the holding since I'm not a Duke, only a Count. Each Holding gets a number of building slots with. Hindu characters will suffer opinion penalties if they have holdings. Masters of Holy Orders. By the way, any time you personally hold a holding of the wrong type, the game will notify you in the same fashion it does when your ruler is not married or you. A city holding. There are four systems of government feudalism, theocracy, republic and tribal. So im still not understanding this right. If you _really_ want a different kind of vassal, you'll need to strip their titles and award to somebody of the desired government type. I'm a Catholic Feudal Count and I've been on a mini conquering spree, took a couple of. I tried mouseover over evertyhing in the temple plus the tribe the temple is in, but there seems to be no solution. Dec 30, 2020 — Category: Ck2 tribal vs feudal. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. Jump to latest Follow Reply. i'm now getting a "holder is of the wrong holding type"-message. I am playing with CK2+ mod and ruler designer - not sure if that matters in this situation. Having 2 castles instead would help you a lot more, especially in terms of army size. You're a feudal lord and he is a pesant, so he will always have a opinion hit towards you. If you want to get rid of this hit, change it to a county. Oh, yes - you also get money from them. Most rulers can only hold one type (the exception being Muslim lords can have mosques as well as castles, and only get the penalty for cities). I don't know why it's there because I have other chiefdoms and those. Jump to latest Follow Reply. The easiest way to deal with this is creating new random vassals for all the cities and churches you have conquered. 1) You need to have an empty holding slot. After the holding type is converted, the holding is transferred to a new character of the province's culture and religion, who becomes your direct vassal. All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos Workshop News Guides Reviews. As a King can only hold two Duchies without a large opinion penalty from. You get the same when you conquer territory in war with a CB that kicks out the previous owner (tribal subjugation, conquest or a holy war for example). This will only work for the subholdings, so for the main holding you're going to have to either give it away to someone else or create a tribal holding in one. Compare CK2 release to CK2 today and you'll see all the lines differences. I suggest that you give the county title to the Baron in that county. . I'm a Norse Tribal Jarl, and captured a feudal county. There's a lot of WIP work but we've mostly moved on to CK3 ; it may well be that this is the last version for CK2 for the foreseeable future. Right now, there's little advantage to putting up with the grief of staying. If I want to stay a Germanic pagan until thie end and spread it through the. If you are tribal, you can't make use of castles. Without mods/cheats you sadly can not change the type of one holding after it is build. Dear CK2 players, Somehow one of my county capitals is a city. Your vassals shouId not revolt unIess you are dóing something. When you start a new game as a count, you will usually have a higher demesne limit than you can utilise with baronies alone. Anyone has any ideas?Crusader Kings 3 features a pretty strong game management system, which also includes buildings and realm holdings management. I don't know why. Tribalism is an early form of government, and one of three playable non-feudal government types in CK2 (the other two being merchant republics and nomadism. 2) (Haven't verified but it's how it worked in CK 2) To build a holding type that is already present in the county the county must already have at least one of each holding type present. So, I'm the king of England. The wrong holding penalty therefore comes up when you are directly in charge of a city or church. 1) Make sure all your vassals are of your religion. . Xaioxaiofan Colonel. more than enough to build a new holding in all of the 900+ counties that. It is easier to make a republic by holy war against other religion than claims against own religion. Having high opinion with someone will lead said character to have friendlier behavior and accept more requests therefrom. . I beat it, get 3 prestige and 0. So a T3 Temple = 1. Mastur Ch33f Sep 19, 2020 @ 1:42am. Opinion is affected by a. Crusader Kings is a historical grand strategy / RPG video game series for PC, Mac, Linux, PlayStation 5 & Xbox Series X|S developed & published by Paradox Interactive. By wrong type of holding I mean being a duke and holding a territory whose ruler should be a bishop. But I can't give it away. The only way to do this is to manually edit the save file, it's a pretty basic, missing function. Always something to learn as they say. . To do this right click the barony in question and "create vassal". I know its late replying to this but I can confirm that this works. I Googled it and the functionality to replace buildings or holding types is not a thing. 403K subscribers in the CrusaderKings community. This means that tax-wise it cannot pay off to hold a. On macOS (US), ⌥Option + 6 enters. Im a duke now and to make a merchant republic I have heard I need to be a king, im assuming the negative opinion modifier for wrong holding type will disappear then so putting that aside Id like to know how to make a bishop the head of a province. I'm told by my Situation report that I have holdings of the wrong type for my government, making them worthless as sources of tax and levies. I gave away the bishopric that I took over, but I still have it and it says that the Chiefdom of Gwynedd is the wrong holding type for me. powered by Peatix : More than a ticket. I hold Leicester as Earl. 3 System - bug is non-system related Platform - Steam Mods - none Severity - Major, all Tribal Holdings useless Description - According to the wiki: 'If a Feudal or Clan ruler owns a Tribe it will gain no taxes or levies from but will have the option to turn it into a Castle at the cost of 500. Anyone has any ideas?Crusader Kings. im playing a game, i beat a muslim place on a holy war and take it over, i now have a wrong type of holding warning. I don't know why it's there. Trying the demo as Mathilda di Canossa, I at one point claimed and conquered a prince-bishopric. I've noticed that the castle garrison is not refilling - is that just because of the New Administration penalty, or is garrison regeneration also being affected by the Wrong Holding Type penalty? What is the exact effect of the Wrong Holding Type penalty? Have a revolt risk modifier until the culture shift to norse and then have the holding change to a tribe rather than a castle. If there is a castle holding in the county, you need to be the holder of that title. I clicked on the construct new holdings button, but it's still grayed out. So im still not understanding this right. All have the same mechanics. Change <type="city_holding"> to <type="castle_holding"> and <type="city_01"> to. Is it possible to change this city into a castle so the wrong holding type penalty will disappear? < > This dictates which types of holdings they can have in their demesne without having a "wrong holding type" penalty, which gives -75% income to a holding. Bishoprics: A middle ground between baronies and cities. As you can see, Temples make 0. In Negev, for example, you don't get much benefit from Petra because Petra is in Baidha-Petra, which is a City Holding (and until Merchant Republics come out, you won't get any benefit from it at all, just like the Doge's Palace in Venice). I have all of Ireland right now (I'm also King of Eire), and I took over Gwynedd from the Petty Kingdom of Gwynedd, but now I have the wrong holding type in my demesne for some reason. Early game they're cheap but get pricey quick. Feudal and clan are both considered "civilised" governments in the sense that you can reform into either of them as a tribal government. last time i tried to get rid of it, i gave it to my half brother and seem to have lost control of it, thank god for autosave. But I can't give it away. I hold Leicester as Earl. Each character type has different types of holdings he can effectivly manage. - Added title history commands 'name', 'adjective', 'reset_name' and 'reset_adjective'. There are five types of settlements, each with a different set of buildings. anyway. Aug 28, 2013. . Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts Log in sign up User account menu 15 ExplanationHow to fix Wrong Holding Type and Wrong Government. These will give you stat increases, decisions and random events! - Don't worry if the upgrade has no immediate effect. FAQ: Wrong Holding/Government Type. What to do with a recently taking temple holding? Kahldris. Crusader Kings II. If you have the wrong holding type you take about 25% of the base income as income. No negative opinions from your vassals or anything like. How do i change these into tribes? (since i assume thats what they. A character is affected by your levy and taxation laws based on their type. And here CK2 handled cities much better - city vassals gave a lot of extra money at the expense of some relation penalty. . last time i tried to get. There are several ways to change government type during the game. Jump to latest Follow Reply. I am listed as the holder of the city of Newark, so I keep getting the "wrong type of holding" alert. It is very misleading.